SPOILED: built to the lens, three-room test (Sun Nov 15 2026, 08:56 to 09:10 ET)
Don asked for one Opus job to try building rooms from generated imagery, to compare with the rooms as built. This is the helper's report, condensed by the director.
Method
Raw frames at 2:52 (tank room), 5:44 (canteen) and 6:06 (lift) from the pkg3n take. Plates from FLUX.2 klein 4B edit on tower 1 with the game frame as the only reference: 2 MP, 4 seeds per room, 14 s each. Depth from MoGe-2. The move is a CPU per-pixel splat with a z-buffer over a filled background, 24 fps, 1080p. An enemy cut from the game frame was placed in each plate as a check.
Verdict per room
- Tank room: the plate wins clearly. Wet quarry tile with puddles and a drain, rust down the walls, tanks on their legs. The back wall and floor hold a 1.5 m push. The sign turns to gibberish, the light goes cool where the game is warm, and near railings break up in the last meter.
- Canteen: better, by less. Stained ceiling tiles, scuffed floor. The plate invented a doorway in a wall that is solid in the game. The near table and chairs come apart in motion.
- Lift: the still is better; the move is unusable. Every gate bar sits in front of a gap nobody saw, and it smears within half a meter.
What broke
- Anything inside about 2.5 m tears once the camera covers half the distance to it.
- Fills behind objects are blurs (a generated clean plate would fix that).
- Near detail goes soft; plates need 1.5 to 2 times screen resolution.
- A 3D enemy in a plate keeps its own lighting and has no contact shadow.
A whole 9 minute rail game this way
- Works for anything over 6 m from the lens, or about 1 m of push. The near 5 m, doors that open and every enemy stay 3D.
- Plates cannot be relit: muzzle flash needs a fake, or relightable plates (untested).
- Generation takes minutes; cleanup takes 2 to 3 hours a plate (layout fixes, real signs, clean plates, proxies, matched light). 40 to 80 plates is 100 to 200 hours.
- Disk: 60 plates at 4K is about 1.3 GB, over the jam's 1 GB; at 2.5K about 0.6 GB.
Could one room be replaced today
No. The only candidate was the tank room's back wall, and a card there would clash with the game's warm light and leave a seam at the floor.
What the director took from it
The plates beat the built rooms on WEAR, not on geometry: stains, wet floors, rust streaks, grime at the foot of walls, water-marked ceiling tiles. That can be put into the real rooms as world-aligned grime layers and streak decals, and was ordered at once (eng11). For a sequel: retest with clean plates, a proxy room and a matched light rig on a slow shot.
Files
sheets/ (comparisons, candidates, depth, keyframes), clips/ (dollies, plain and with an enemy), plates/, depth/, frames/, scripts/.