Action bible: Thunder on the Midway
Thu Nov 12, 23:40. Written for Don's direction of 23:10: describe every action, give each the right skeleton and clip, and make the physics of every object right. It covers the three takes and their branches, the three walk-throughs and the three between-scene beats, as they stand in game/takes/*.take.json at commit 961e2ed. This file analyses them and changes nothing; the take JSONs are untouched.
The research, the methods and the plan are in game/ACTIONS-PLAN.md.
How to read the tables
- Time is film seconds in the take. Branches and resets show their sequence-only start (
@110) and the cue they answer. - Skeleton:
MH-Rexis the Rex_final MetaHuman body (clips in/Game/Motion/Kimodo),MH-Heavyis Heavy_v1, Jorge, with his own MetaHuman body (/Game/Motion/KimodoHeavy), andMH-Waltis Walt_v3 (/Game/Motion/KimodoWalt). Every clip is Kimodo SOMA77, retargeted with IK_SOMA to the MetaHuman IK rig. The fingers carry no authored motion (see the plan, section 3).nonemeans a placeholder engine shape with no skeleton. Props are static meshes unless the row says so. - Clip: the tag as the take uses it, with its modifiers (
rate,travelscale, keyedslide,lift,arc,tilt). - Status, worst first:
MOTION WRONG: the motion doesn't match what the row describes, or the take moves the root by keys (a slide, lift or ramp that breaks Don's no-slides rule).PROP ABSENT: the action needs a prop the take doesn't place where the action happens.PROP STATIC: the prop is there but doesn't react the way it physically should.NO CLIP: no clip exists, or the miss is HUD only. STANDARDS (Game director) says a miss must play a blended, pre-authored variation, so a HUD-only miss is a gap.CONTACT MISSING: a hand or foot is meant to meet a prop or a body, and nothing places it there. Contact is unmeasured in every take: no take has a contact check, only the pop gate (under 4.5 cm a frame) and the gag checks.OK: reads right as far as the data shows. These rows are unmeasured too; OK means no known gap.
Take 1: the chase (chase.take.json, 45 s, midway)
| ID | Time (s) | Who | Action | Body contacts | Props and what must physically happen | Clip now | Skeleton | Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| C01 | 0.0-2.6 | Kid | Walks onto his mark | Feet on dirt | none | walk_to_mark_s2 | MH-Rex | OK |
| C02 | 0-45 | Walt | Stands off to the side, claps on action, shouts cut | Feet on dirt, hands clap | Flat cap stays on the head socket | idle_director_s7, clap_once_s6, shout_cut_s4 | MH-Walt | OK |
| C03 | 2.6-15.6 | Money man | Runs ahead with the take, leads Kid to the truck | Feet on dirt | none | none: a placeholder cylinder moved linearly from x 900 to 6200 | none | NO CLIP |
| C04 | 2.6-4.6 | Kid | Sprints after him | Feet on dirt | none | chase_sprint_s7 | MH-Rex | OK |
| C05 | 4.6-9.0, cue c1_vault 5.2 | Kid | Vaults sideways over the popcorn cart with one hand and keeps running | One hand planted on the cart top, the legs clear it | Cart takes the weight: a small rock on its wheels, popcorn shakes in the glass case | take_chase_split_a_s79 | MH-Rex | CONTACT MISSING (cart is a 90 cm box staged 140 cm ahead of the pelvis; the hand plant isn't aligned or measured; the cart doesn't rock) |
| C06 | @110, c1_vault flub | Kid | Trailing foot catches the cart, he tumbles over head first, rolls and runs on | Foot hits the cart's top edge, hands then shoulder roll on the ground | Cart rocks hard or tips onto two wheels, popcorn spills (popcart_crash plays) | vault_tumble_roll_on_s33 | MH-Rex | PROP STATIC (cart doesn't move; the rejoin eases the root back onto the path, a slide risk) |
| C07 | 9.0-13.0, cue c2_slide 9.6 | Kid | Slides under the swing gate as it closes, springs up | Hip and thigh slide on the dirt, the gate passes over the chest | Gate swings closed on its hinge over him and settles | take_chase_split_b_s53, rate 0.85, trim 1.4, z_w 0.6 | MH-Rex | PROP STATIC (gate is a static box; z_w 0.6 flattens the pelvis height, so check the hip on the ground) |
| C08 | @70, c2_slide wreck | Kid, crew | Too slow: the gate bumps his chest, he sits up rubbing it; the crew resets the gate in shot | Chest against the gate edge, seat on the dirt | Gate stops on his chest and swings back; a crew member pulls it open | gate_too_slow_s6 | MH-Rex, crew none | PROP STATIC (gate static; no crew) |
| C09 | 13.0-16.0, cue c3_mirror 13.4 | Kid | Pushes off a mirror panel with his left hand | Hand flat on the glass | Mirror panel flexes in its frame, reflection wobbles | mirror_stumble_s2 | MH-Rex | PROP ABSENT (no mirror in the take; the maze facade is at 3200,-840, off his path) |
| C10 | @125, c3_mirror flub | Kid | Spins and walks into the glass, bounces off, runs on | Shoulder and forehead on the glass | Panel shakes; a crack is optional (mirror_hit, glass_clink play) | mirror_bounce_on_s11, travel 0.3 | MH-Rex | PROP ABSENT (travel 0.3 scales the path, a foot-slide risk) |
| C11 | 16.0-20.5, cues c4_leap 16.4, c5_hang 17.2 | Kid | Leaps for the moving truck's tailgate, catches it and is dragged | Both hands hooked over the tailgate edge, feet off the ground or dragging | Truck drives on (14.0-24.0, 14 m); he must move with it | take_chase_split_c_s36 | MH-Rex | MOTION WRONG (his root comes from the clip and isn't parented to the moving truck, so the hands can't stay on the tailgate) |
| C12 | @80, c4_leap wreck | Kid, truck | Fingers slip off the tailgate, he sits down hard; the truck backs up for the reset | Fingers on the edge, then seat on the dirt | Truck backs up in shot | tailgate_miss_s5 | MH-Rex | CONTACT MISSING (the grab isn't aligned to the edge; no truck reverse is keyed) |
| C13 | c5_hang miss | Kid | Lets go early and drops into the hay a beat early | Drops from the tailgate onto hay | Hay takes him | none, HUD only | MH-Rex | NO CLIP |
| C14 | 20.5-24.9 | Kid | Thrown off the truck, lands on his back in the hay, rolls to his knees | Back into the hay, knees on the ground | Hay pile compresses, straw and loose bales scatter | hay_throw_land_s6, hold | MH-Rex | PROP ABSENT (no hay in the take; nobody on the truck throws him) |
| C15 | 24.9-27.8 | Kid | Gets up and dusts off | Feet, hands on knees | none | dust_off_s18 | MH-Rex | OK |
| C16 | 27.8-30.8, cue m1_mirror 28.8 | Kid | Second mirror run: shoulder bounces off the glass to the right | Shoulder on the glass | Panel shakes | mirror_stumble_s11, trim 0.3 | MH-Rex | PROP ABSENT |
| C17 | @140, m1_mirror flub | Kid | Spins round and staggers into the glass | Hands and shoulder on the glass | Panel shakes, glass rattles | mirror_dizzy_s1 | MH-Rex | PROP ABSENT |
| C18 | 30.8-33.7, cues t1_leap 32.55, t2_hang 33.2 | Kid | Leaps for the tailgate again, hangs, pulls his knees up onto the bed | Hands hooked on the edge, then knees on the bed | Truck rolls to a stop (27.0-32.0) | tailgate_leap_s3 | MH-Rex | MOTION WRONG (the next clip adds lift 114 at 33.7, so the body rises 114 cm across a 0.25 s blend unless the leap ends on the bed; hands and knees aren't aligned) |
| C19 | @90, t1_leap wreck | Kid | Slips off the edge and hangs from it, legs kicking, pulls up | Both hands on the bed edge, full weight | Truck bed dips a little under his weight | truck_hang_on_s37, shift 40 | MH-Rex | CONTACT MISSING |
| C20 | t2_hang miss | Kid | Lets go before the knees are up | Drops off the tailgate | none | none, HUD only | MH-Rex | NO CLIP |
| C21 | 33.7-45 and @200 | Kid | Stands on the bed, dusts off, bows ("Now that's a stunt") | Feet on the truck bed | none | dust_off_s1 rate 0.8, bow_to_crew_s13 rate 0.608, both lift 114 | MH-Rex | MOTION WRONG (feet 46 cm inside the placeholder box, whose top is 160 cm; the take notes say lift 160; recheck against the real flatbed's bed height) |
| C22 | 14.0-24.0, 27.0-32.0 | Truck | Drives off with the money, later stops | Wheels on the road | Wheels turn at distance over radius, the body pitches on starting and stopping, dust | keyed transform, smooth ease | none | PROP STATIC (a sliding box: no wheel roll, no pitch, no driver) |
Take 2: the beer tent brawl (brawl.take.json, 45 s, beertent)
| ID | Time (s) | Who | Action | Body contacts | Props and what must physically happen | Clip now | Skeleton | Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| B01 | 0.0-4.02 | Kid | Nervous on his mark | Feet on boards | none | mark_check_nervous_s6, rate 0.88 | MH-Rex | OK |
| B02 | 0.0-5.6 | Heavy | Waits, dusts off | Feet on boards | none | dust_off_s1, mark_check_nervous_s6 | MH-Heavy | OK |
| B03 | 4.02-8.73, cues b1_duck 5.14, b2_uppercut 6.21 | Kid, Heavy | The heavy throws a wild swing; Kid ducks under it and comes up with an uppercut | Heavy's fist passes over Kid's head; Kid's fist meets the heavy's jaw at 6.21 | none | Kid brawl_beat_a_s17 rate 0.7; Heavy haymaker_take_s13 at 5.6, travel 0.2 | MH-Rex, MH-Heavy | MOTION WRONG (the heavy never swings: he plays taking a hit; heavy_wild_swing_miss_s12 exists and isn't used here; fist to jaw is unmeasured) |
| B04 | @110, b1_duck flub | Kid | Sells too early: throws himself over the table before the punch, peeks up | Body over the table top | Table and mugs jolt | haymaker_early_sell_s2 | MH-Rex | PROP ABSENT (the table is staged for 14.3 s, not here; the rejoin eases the root, a slide risk) |
| B05 | b2_uppercut miss | Heavy | Shrugs off a weak uppercut | none | none | none, HUD only (heavy_shrug_off_s11 exists) | MH-Heavy | NO CLIP |
| B06 | 8.73-11.9, cue b3_sell 9.43 | Kid, Heavy | The heavy lands a haymaker; Kid sells it with a full spin | Heavy's fist on Kid's jaw at 9.43 | none | Kid brawl_beat_b_s1 travel 0.5; Heavy dust_off_s1 at 7.9, mark_check_nervous_s6 at 11.6 | MH-Rex, MH-Heavy | MOTION WRONG (Kid sells a punch nobody throws; heavy_haymaker_throw_s10 exists and isn't used here; travel 0.5 is a foot-slide risk) |
| B07 | @70, b3_sell wreck | Kid | Spins the wrong way into the chair and staggers (reset) | Chair across the back | Chair breaks across him | chair_eat_stagger_s6 | MH-Rex | MOTION WRONG (no chair is in anyone's hand at 9.4 s: it scales in at 14.6; no heavy action; the chair doesn't break) |
| B08 | 11.9-17.6, cue b4_table 13.18 (hold) | Kid, Heavy | The heavy shoves him in the chest; he flies back onto the long table, slides along it on his back and rolls off the far end | Heavy's hands on Kid's chest; Kid's back, then hip, on the table top; feet land on the far side | Mugs on the table scatter and spill, benches scrape; the table jolts but stands (beat 2 says "we broke the table", see note 1) | Kid brawl_beat_c_s7 rate 0.85, travel 0.5; Heavy mark_check_nervous_s6 | MH-Rex, MH-Heavy | MOTION WRONG (no shove; travel 0.5 halves the slide, so his back slides against the clip's own motion; mugs static) |
| B09 | @125, b4_table flub | Kid | Stalls halfway along the table, rolls off sideways, fists up | Back on the table, feet on the floor | Mugs jolt | table_short_roll_s17, lift_cm 61.5 while the pelvis is under 70 cm | MH-Rex | CONTACT MISSING (a lift hack, not a contact; 61.5 cm assumes the placeholder table scale) |
| B10 | 14.1-21.1, cue b5_chair 15.86 | Heavy | Grabs a wooden chair, swings it two-handed, smashes it down on the table edge as Kid rolls clear, drops the leg he's left holding | Both hands on the chair back, then one hand on a broken leg | Chair taken from its spot on the floor (set chair_0 to chair_4), shatters on impact at 15.95 (chair_smash): seat, legs and splinters fly and settle; the leg stays in his hand and is dropped; pieces stay on the floor for the rest of the take | brawl_chair_swing_s15; chair attached to hand_r with scale keys 0 at 0.0, 1 at 14.6, 0 at 16.2 | MH-Heavy | PROP STATIC (the chair pops into one hand from nothing and pops out of existence; no break, no second hand, no pieces) |
| B11 | @80, b5_chair wreck | Kid, Heavy | The breakaway chair catches him; he's down; reset | Chair across the shoulders | Chair breaks across him | chair_whiff_s7 (prompt: ducks a chair that misses, is shoved over by another man) | MH-Rex | MOTION WRONG (the clip shows a miss, the wreck says a hit; no chair swing and no shover in the reset) |
| B12 | 17.6-21.3 | Kid | Dusts off | Feet | none | dust_off_s1 | MH-Rex | OK |
| B13 | 18.0-23.3 | Heavy | Waits | Feet | none | mark_check_nervous_s6, hold | MH-Heavy | OK |
| B14 | 21.3-24.6, cue r1_swing 23.15 | Kid | Runs, jumps, grabs the rigging rope with both hands, swings and kicks the heavy with both feet, lets go, lands | Both hands gripping the rope overhead, both feet into the heavy's chest | Rope swings from its anchor under his weight, carries him, swings back free after release; the tent rigging shakes | rope_swing_kick_s1 with a keyed slide of 240 cm from 1.0 to 2.4 s | MH-Rex | MOTION WRONG (the 240 cm keyed root slide breaks the no-slides rule and drags the hands along a fixed rope; the rope is a static cylinder) |
| B15 | 23.3-24.6 | Heavy | Takes both feet in the chest, staggers back | Kid's feet on his chest | none | haymaker_take_s13, travel 0.3 | MH-Heavy | CONTACT MISSING |
| B16 | @140, r1_swing flub | Kid | Jumps late, misses the rope, goes flat on his chest | Chest and hands on the boards | Rope swings lightly from the brush | flub_late_jump_s25 | MH-Rex | OK (the rejoin eases the root, a slide risk; see the seam audit) |
| B17 | 24.6-28.85, cue s1_upper 25.3 | Kid, Heavy | The heavy swings wild and misses; Kid ducks and lands the uppercut; the heavy shrugs it off | Heavy's fist over Kid's head; Kid's fist on the jaw at 25.3 | none | Kid brawl_uppercut_s3 hold, keyed slide 30 cm; Heavy heavy_wild_swing_miss_s12, heavy_shrug_off_s11 | MH-Rex, MH-Heavy | MOTION WRONG (keyed 30 cm slide; fist to jaw unmeasured) |
| B18 | s1_upper miss | Heavy | Shrugs it off anyway | none | none | none, HUD only | MH-Heavy | NO CLIP |
| B19 | 28.6-31.45, cue s2_fall 30.25 | Heavy, Kid | The heavy throws the haymaker; Kid flies back off the bandstand, through its boards, onto his back | Heavy's fist on Kid's jaw about 29.6; Kid's back through the bandstand deck | Bandstand rail and deck boards break (chair_smash, glass_smash play), a music stand and glasses on it go over, dust | Heavy heavy_haymaker_throw_s10; Kid bandstand_fall_s1 (falls about 1 m from a raised platform) | MH-Heavy, MH-Rex | PROP ABSENT (the bandstand is at 1537,-35 and the fall lands near x 0; he starts on the floor, so the 1 m drop has no platform; nothing breaks) |
| B20 | @155, s2_fall flub | Kid | Gets up wrong, limps off rubbing his back, rejoins at the bow | Feet, hand on lower back | none | limp_off_s2 | MH-Rex | OK |
| B21 | 31.2-45 and @200 | Kid, Heavy | Dust off, bow to the crew, Rex's "adequate", print | Feet | none | dust_off_s18, bow_to_crew_s13, dust_off_s1; Heavy dust_off_s1, mark_check_nervous_s6 | MH-Rex, MH-Heavy | OK |
| B22 | 0-45 | Walt | Idle, clap, cut, facepalm in resets, applause | Hands clap | Cap on the head socket | idle_director_s7 and the rest | MH-Walt | OK |
| B23 | 0-45 | Crowd | Drinkers cheer, gasp and laugh at the fight | Seated or standing at tables | Mugs clink and get knocked over | none (crowd sfx with no extras) | none | NO CLIP |
| B24 | 2.3-33.45 | Mugs and glasses | Clink on the tables; one smashes at 30.45 | none | Glass shatters and spills | static set mugs; glass_smash plays over nothing | none | PROP STATIC |
| B25 | 21.3-24.6 | Tent | Canvas and rigging shake when the rope takes weight | none | Canvas ripple at the rope anchor | static tent shell | none | PROP STATIC |
| B26 | Director's Cut | Kid, Heavy | The kung fu version of beats 2 to 4 | as authored | as authored | kungfu.take.json doesn't exist | MH-Rex, MH-Heavy | NO CLIP |
Take 3: the cannon (cannon.take.json, 45 s, cannonfield)
| ID | Time (s) | Who | Action | Body contacts | Props and what must physically happen | Clip now | Skeleton | Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| K01 | 0.0-7.6 | Kid | Nervous on his mark, walks in behind the cannon | Feet | none | mark_check_nervous_s6, walk_to_mark_s2 | MH-Rex | OK |
| K02 | 7.6-11.4, cue k1_wave 9.2 | Kid | Waves to the grandstand | Feet | none | cannon_wave_crowd_s31 | MH-Rex | OK |
| K03 | @140, k1_wave flub | Kid | Freezes and fidgets on his mark | Feet | none | mark_check_nervous_s6 | MH-Rex | OK (a weak variation, but it fits the line) |
| K04 | 11.4-14.2, cue k2_five 13.05 | Kid, Walt | High five on the way past | Kid's right palm on Walt's raised right palm | none | Kid high_five_crew_s2; Walt clap_once_s6 at 12.45 | MH-Rex, MH-Walt | MOTION WRONG (Walt claps his own hands, never raises one; the palms never meet) |
| K05 | k2_five miss | Walt | Left hanging: hand up, waits, lowers it | none | none | none, HUD only | MH-Walt | NO CLIP |
| K06 | 14.2-16.0 | Kid | Runs for the platform | Feet | none | chase_sprint_s7, trim 1.4 | MH-Rex | OK |
| K07 | 16.0-21.8 | Kid | Bounds up the steps onto the 2 m platform at the muzzle | Feet on each step, a hand on the rail | Steps flex a little | walk_to_mark_s2 with lift keys 0 to 200 cm over 1.2 s and a keyed slide of (4, 61) cm | MH-Rex | MOTION WRONG (a flat walk lifted 2 m by keys: he floats up through a box with no steps) |
| K08 | 21.8-26.3 | Kid | Waves to the crowd from the platform | Feet on the platform top (200 cm) | none | cannon_wave_crowd_s39, lift 200, face_raw | MH-Rex | OK |
| K09 | 26.3-29.3, cue c1_in 26.59 (hold) | Kid | Swings his legs into the barrel and slides down inside until only his head shows | Hands on the muzzle rim, legs into the bore | Barrel takes his weight | cannon_climb_in_s17, lift 200 (the clip climbs a ladder first) | MH-Rex | CONTACT MISSING (no ladder; the rim at (0, 0, 270) isn't aligned to the hands; the body doesn't go into the bore) |
| K10 | c1_in miss | Kid | Stalls on the rim, scrambles, slides in late | Hands on the rim | none | none, HUD only | MH-Rex | NO CLIP |
| K11 | 29.3-32.22, cue c2_fire 29.45 | Kid | Fired from the cannon: flies about 23 m in a ballistic arc, 5.4 m apex, head first, arms forward | none in the air | none | cannon_launch_flight_s11 at rate 0.2 from 1.5 s, the root locked to a keyed parabola, tilt keys 0 to 100 deg about the pelvis | MH-Rex | MOTION WRONG (an upright leap slowed 5x and tipped forward as a whole, not a flight pose; Don wants keyed flight in Blender) |
| K12 | 29.45 | Cannon | Fires | none | Barrel recoils along its axis and returns, muzzle flash and smoke, carriage jolts | muzzle light cue only | none | PROP STATIC |
| K13 | @110, c2_fire flub | Kid | The cannon coughs: a short, low flight and a belly flop onto the crash pad | Chest and thighs on the pad | Pad compresses and rebounds, the bed bounces | cannon_belly_flop_s25 on a keyed arc, ramp_from 0.5 | MH-Rex | PROP STATIC (pad static; ramp_from eases the root onto the main path, a slide risk) |
| K14 | 32.22-34.4, cues c3_tuck 32.31, c4_land 33.02 | Kid, truck | Tucks, lands on the truck bed, rolls to his feet | Feet then back and shoulder on the bed | Truck suspension dips under the landing and recovers; in the story the truck is the robbers' and moving | cannon_tuck_land_s20, trim 1.7, on the arc, post_k 0.5 | MH-Rex | PROP STATIC (truck static, no suspension; post_k 0.5 scales the roll, a slide risk) |
| K15 | c3_tuck miss | Kid | Opens up early and lands stiff, stumbles | Feet on the bed | Bed dips | none, HUD only | MH-Rex | NO CLIP |
| K16 | @70, c4_land wreck | Kid | Lands on the bed's rear edge, slips off, hangs by his hands, the crew resets | Both hands hooked over the rear edge (x 2000, z 120), full weight | Bed dips under his weight | cannon_land_slip_hang_s36, shift -220, lift keys 120 to 15 to 120 cm | MH-Rex | CONTACT MISSING (the lift keys move the whole body down and up again under the hands; nothing pins the hands to the edge) |
| K17 | 34.4-45 and @200 | Kid | Bows on the bed, "my stunt double", dusts off | Feet on the bed (top 120) | none | bow_to_crew_s13, dust_off_s1, lift 120 | MH-Rex | OK |
| K18 | 0-45 | Walt | Idle, claps, cut | Hands | Cap | idle_director_s7, clap_once_s6, shout_cut_s4 | MH-Walt | OK |
| K19 | 7.6-11.4, 33.0 | Crowd | The grandstand waves back, cheers the landing | Seated | none | none | none | NO CLIP |
| K20 | 0-45 | Flags and pennants | Flutter in the wind | none | Cloth moves | static flag meshes | none | PROP STATIC |
Walk-throughs (walk_chase, walk_brawl, walk_cannon)
Props are meant to stay still in a walk-through: Walt only points at them. Gaps here are consistency with the takes.
| ID | Time (s) | Who | Action | Body contacts | Props and what must physically happen | Clip now | Skeleton | Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| W01 | 0-6.6 (all three) | Kid, Walt | Walk side by side to the mark | Feet | none | walk_to_mark_s2 on both, same start time | MH-Rex, MH-Walt | OK (both play the same clip in lockstep; offset Walt's start by about 0.4 s or give him his own walk) |
| W02 | 4-26 (all three) | Walt | Points out each stunt; arms folded during Kid's line | none | none | point_action_s1, idle_director_s7, arms_folded_watch_s9 | MH-Walt | OK |
| W03 | 6.6 on (all three) | Kid | Listens on his mark | Feet | none | mark_check_nervous_s6, hold | MH-Rex | OK |
| W04 | inserts | walk_chase | Insert of the mirror maze front | none | Facade at 3200,-840 until batch 15 imports | set piece | none | PROP ABSENT (until the facade imports; the take has no mirror on Kid's path either, see C09) |
| W05 | inserts | walk_brawl | Insert of the rope and the bandstand | none | Rope mesh path /Game/Props/SM_rigging_rope differs from the take's /Game/Sets/beertent/...; the bandstand is at 1537,-35, but the take's fall lands near x 0 | static | none | MOTION WRONG (shows a different rope asset and a bandstand that isn't where the fall happens, see B19) |
| W06 | inserts | walk_cannon | Wide of the cannon on its platform | none | The platform uses SM_bandstand_section; the take uses SM_cannon_platform | static | none | MOTION WRONG (a different platform from the take) |
Between-scene beats (beat_1, beat_2, beat_3, Stage 7)
| ID | Time (s) | Who | Action | Body contacts | Props and what must physically happen | Clip now | Skeleton | Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| S01 | 2.0-8 (all three) | Walt | The squawk box buzzes; Walt leans to it, presses the talk key and answers the front office | Finger on the talk key, hand on the box or apple box | Key goes down, a light comes on; phone_ring, phone_squawk and phone_click are not mapped yet | point_action_s1 (beat 1, 3), shout_cut_s4 (beat 2) | MH-Walt | NO CLIP (no reach-and-press clip; Walt points at the air) |
| S02 | 0-36 (all three) | Rex | Fusses by the craft table about his close-up | Hand on a cup or a mirror, touching his hair | Cup lifted and put down | mark_check_nervous_s6 looped 10 to 11 times, 4 s apart (beat 3 adds one bow) | MH-Rex | MOTION WRONG (the same 4 s fidget repeats ten times; no craft table business; nothing reads as vanity) |
| S03 | 7.7-18 (all three) | Walt | Answers Rex, arms folded | none | none | arms_folded_watch_s9, idle_director_s7 | MH-Walt | OK |
| S04 | good and rough branches | Walt | Claps at good dailies, facepalms at rough | Hands, palm on face | none | clap_once_s6, facepalm_s7 | MH-Walt | OK |
| S05 | 0-40 (all three) | Squawk box | Sits on the apple box by the chair | none | none | placeholder box | none | PROP ABSENT (placeholder until SM_squawk_box is made) |
Note 1, continuity: beat 2 has Walt say "Yes, we broke the table. It's a breakaway table", but in the brawl the table never breaks (STORY.md: "a table slide"). Either the table collapses at the end of B08 (a second breakable, after Kid rolls off) or the line changes. My take: break it. A trestle that folds after the slide is a better gag, and the line already pays it off.
Gap summary, worst first
Counts over the 79 rows above:
| Status | Rows |
|---|---|
| MOTION WRONG | 16 |
| PROP ABSENT | 9 |
| PROP STATIC | 11 |
| NO CLIP | 12 |
| CONTACT MISSING | 7 |
| OK | 24 |
| Gaps in all | 55 of 79 |
Ranked by what a player sees on a print (main path first), then by how bad it reads:
- B10 The breakaway chair pops into one hand from nothing and pops out of existence on the smash; it never breaks. This is the brawl's signature prop.
- B06 Kid sells a haymaker the heavy never throws.
- B03 Kid ducks a wild swing the heavy never throws; the uppercut's fist to jaw is unmeasured.
- B08 Kid is shoved down the table by a heavy who is standing still; travel 0.5 halves the slide against the clip's own motion; the mugs don't react.
- C11 Kid hangs on a moving truck's tailgate while his root follows the clip, not the truck. His hands can't stay on it.
- K07 Kid floats 2 m up onto the cannon platform: a flat walk lifted by keys, with no steps.
- B14 Rope swing: a 240 cm keyed root slide, and a static rope that carries no weight.
- B19 The fall through the bandstand happens about 15 m from the bandstand; nothing breaks. The 1 m drop has no platform.
- K11 and K12 The cannon flight is a slowed, tipped leap clip. The cannon has no recoil or smoke.
- C14, C09, C16 The hay and the mirrors are missing from the chase: Kid lands on and bounces off nothing.
After those: K04 (a high five where the palms never meet), C21 (feet 46 cm inside the truck box), C18 (a 114 cm lift pop), B17 (a 30 cm slide), C03 (the money man is a sliding cylinder), the 12 NO CLIP rows (eight HUD-only misses that break the STANDARDS rule, the crowds, the beats' squawk box and the kung fu take), then the PROP STATIC rows for cart, gate, truck, cannon, pad, glass, tent and flags, then the CONTACT MISSING rows. Every keyed slide, lift_keys, travel under 1 and branch rejoin ramp is a slide in the STANDARDS sense, so it belongs to the seam audit as well as to this file.
Brawl rebuild, Fri Nov 13 (game/takes/brawl2_take.py, build D:\megajam\builds\brawl2)
What the rebuild did to the brawl rows, by numbers from the director build's layout (game/takes/brawl2/brawl2_plan.py) and from the packaged game's joint log (game/takes/brawl2/seam_check.py). Seam numbers are in game/takes/SEAMS.md. Nobody has looked at a frame.
| # | Now | Status |
|---|---|---|
| B03 | The heavy throws heavy_wild_swing_miss_s12 at 4.81 s (fist fastest on the duck cue) and takes the uppercut with haymaker_take_s13 at 6.31 s, once his missed swing has spun him right round | CONTACT MISSING: Kid's fist stays about 108 cm from the jaw. Kid's beat_a backs away 47 cm while he punches, and the heavy's swing leaves him 33 cm further back. It needs a two-man clip or a step in |
| B05, B18 | No clip | NO CLIP, as before (HUD only) |
| B06 | The heavy throws heavy_haymaker_throw_s10 at 8.26 s, turned to face Kid, fist fastest at 9.43 s | CONTACT MISSING: the fist passes about 128 cm from Kid's head. Same cause |
| B07 | Wreck reset is eat_the_chair-s16 (batch 20), fitted on the main pose at the judge time: pose gap 0.13 cm in, 0.56 cm out. The heavy's haymaker carries on through it, so he spins into the punch, not a chair | OK as a cut; the name says chair, the action is a punch |
| B08 | The heavy walks in (walk_to_mark_s2, 10.95 s) and shoves with brawl_shove_chest_s3 at 12.38 s: right wrist 20 cm from Kid's chest joint at 13.10 s, left 38 cm (palms on the chest is about 20) | OK for the shove. The table is not under him: beat_c is a stagger with a dip of the hips, not a slide, and the table stands where the chair lands. travel 0.5 is still on beat_b and beat_c, because the batch 20 branches were made on that path |
| B09 | Flub is short_slide-s14, constrained: pose gap 1.46 cm in, 0.51 cm out, pelvis 4.6 cm spread over 4.3 s. No lift | CONTACT MISSING: he lies on the boards, not on a table |
| B10 | Keyed two-handed swing (cs_heavy_chair_swing_2h, re-keyed for the heavy's measured size), 13.95 s, impact 15.95 s. The chair stands at its spot from the first frame, both wrists on the rail from frame 13 (0.0 cm off the authored points; up to 3.2 cm short while he reaches down), swaps to 30 baked pieces on the impact frame, the kept leg drops 0.5 s later, pieces stay | OK. One piece of 30 travels 9 m in the bake |
| B10 table | Breakaway table (SK_trestle_breakaway): the top snaps in the middle under the chair, both halves hinge down on the trestles, the stretcher falls flat; the chair pieces were baked against the same falling halves. Kid stands 26 cm clear of its footprint | OK ("we broke the table") |
| B11 | Wreck reset is chair_whiff-s25: pose gap 0.01 cm in, 0.70 cm out | MOTION WRONG: the clip is a man swinging and stumbling, not a man hit by a chair, and the chair has already landed when the judge calls it (cue 15.86 s, judge 16.29 s, impact 15.95 s). No bot run reaches it (a missed b4 swallows b5) |
| B13 | The heavy backs away to his mark for the rope gag: walk_to_mark_s2 played backwards, five times on one line, travel 1.03 | MOTION WRONG, small: 3 percent foot slide, and each repeat joins on a hip turn of about 30 degrees |
| B14 | Keyed rope swing kick (vr_kid_rope_swing_kick, re-keyed on tower 2: pad at the heavy's real sternum height, anchor 7.0 m up after Rex's 1.147 scale), wrists pinned to the rope (0.0 cm off the authored points). No slide | OK |
| B15 | Keyed pull-back (vr_heavy_pullback) on his mark: Kid's soles 16 to 20 cm ahead of the heavy's chest joint, centred within 10 cm | OK |
| B16 | Flub is rope_miss_long-s33, locked on its exit (0.07 cm), rejoins at 29.2167 s and swallows s1_upper (scored as missed, never called) | MOTION WRONG at the entry: the clip was made against rope_swing_kick_s1, which the keyed swing replaced. Pose gap 125 cm over a 0.4 s crossfade |
| B17 | Unchanged clips | CONTACT MISSING, worse than it looked: the keyed kick leaves the two men about 1.9 to 2.1 m apart, so the wild swing passes 144 cm from Kid's head and his uppercut 124 cm from the jaw |
| B19 | The heavy walks back in (26.75 s) and throws the haymaker; Kid falls flat on his back on the boards | CONTACT MISSING (fist about 98 cm from the head, and low). PROP ABSENT stays: the bandstand cannot stand under the fall, because the rope swing comes in along the same line one beat earlier (see SEAMS.md). The smash sounds that had nothing to break are gone |
| B20 | Flub is bad_landing-s22, constrained: 0.00 cm in, 0.6 cm out after a 0.25 s crossfade | OK |
| B24 | Three candy-glass mugs on the fight table shatter with it (six shards each, ballistic); the dressing mugs are unchanged | OK for the three |
| B25 | The rope is a 20-bone chain through the canvas to the grid; the canvas itself does not move | PROP STATIC (canvas) |