scores-KK.md
Source theme-day/scores-KK.md. Last git commit 2026-11-11. About 999 words.
Scores: Kid Katapult, Director's Cut (take KK)
Fresh panel, Wed Nov 11 evening. Method from prep/PLAYBOOK.md "How to score": 7 criteria at 1 to 5 per judge, total = judge average + 2 x feasibility (max 45).
Judge scores
| Criterion | J1 Epic judge | J2 Player/streamer | J3 UE tech artist |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ambition and innovation | 3 | 4 | 3 |
| Theme | 3 | 3 | 3 |
| Fun | 4 | 5 | 4 |
| Gameplay | 3 | 3 | 3 |
| Visuals | 4 | 4 | 4 |
| Level design | 4 | 4 | 4 |
| Audio | 4 | 4 | 4 |
| Total | 25 | 27 | 25 |
Average: 25.7.
J1 (Epic judge). Film sets will be the most common Director's Cut setting in the field. A stunt double on a collapsing soundstage is the third or fourth one this judge sees, and "the cut stunt" reads as theme dressing: the core verb is run, jump and roll, which is any platformer. Points for a clean set piece and Sequencer craft if it lands. Theme 3 because the cut idea is in the framing, not in the verb.
J2 (player and streamer). The best clip in the room: a stunt run with the set falling, a director yelling marks, "Print it" at the end. Fun is obvious in the first minute and a fail retake is funny on stream. Gameplay 3 because one linear take has little replay unless retakes or grades add depth.
J3 (UE tech artist). Chaos fracture, Niagara dust and sparks, Lumen through stage rigs and MetaSound hitting cues all passed our 5.9 gate and are strengths. The risk is the body: a third person stuntman is seen up close for 10 minutes, and every hitch in a roll or landing shows. Contact (grabbing ledges, being hit) is our weak spot per METHODS.md.
Feasibility
As pitched: 2. Riskiest system: the hero's stunt move set (run, leap, roll, duck, ledge catch, falls) with clean transitions under player control, plus any second body the stunt touches. PLAYBOOK's animation-heavy shape is rated 2 for this reason. Greybox of the core verb: about 16 hours as pitched (move set, marks system, triggered collapses), over the 12 hour row.
Scoped (below): 3. Starting from the UE 5.9 third person template, Manny already runs and jumps; roll and duck come from Kimodo through AnimGenOffline with auto retarget to Manny, two or three clips. Greybox: about 10 to 12 hours. No hand contact, no two body moments.
Total and rank
- As pitched: 25.7 + 4 = 29.7, and feasibility 2 trips the gate (under 3). Cut.
- Scoped: 25.7 + 6 = 31.7.
| Take | Total |
|---|---|
| Ballast | 36.0 |
| Coverage (R1) | 35.7 |
| Projectionist (R1) | 35.3 |
| The Shelf | 34.7 |
| The Unabridged | 34.0 |
| Prune | 31.7 to 33.7 |
| Kid Katapult, scoped | 31.7 |
| Kid Katapult, as pitched | 29.7 (gate cut) |
| Foreman of the Deep | cut |
Scoped, it ties Prune's floor and sits last among the live finalists. Its judge average (25.7) is middle of the pack; the build cost sinks it.
Verdict
Viable only if heavily scoped, and even then it is not the best use of the jam. The pitch's strengths (cinematics, audio, destruction) are things Unreal does well; its weakness is the thing we do worst, a humanoid hero seen up close doing contact moves for 10 minutes. And the film set setting will be crowded.
Scope that makes it viable:
- One picture: one soundstage, one continuous take of about 5 minutes of play, plus a Sequencer cold open and the "Print it" ending. Retakes on failure, graded by the director (takes counted, marks hit).
- Genre: a 1960s spy picture set (rooftop, gantry, collapsing facade). It gives clear marks, explosions that sell Chaos and Niagara, and a score with brass hits on cues. Avoid Western or action clichés that read as a parody of a known film.
- Stunt verbs: run, leap (template jump), roll (one Kimodo clip, triggered on landing marks), duck or slide (one Kimodo clip). Four verbs, no ledge grabs, no climbing, no fights. Falls happen as ragdoll on failure, which is funny and needs no authored motion.
- Humanoids: two at most. Kid (Manny, playable) and the director, who stays seated on a crane or behind the camera with an idle and a few Kimodo gestures. Crew are silhouettes or offscreen voices. No touching between bodies.
- Motion in UE 5.9: template locomotion for run and jump; roll, duck and the director's gestures from Kimodo via AnimGenOffline in the editor, auto retargeted to Manny, with Claude key poses to steer them per METHODS.md. Root motion off; drive the roll distance from code. Everything rated through the review gate before Don sees it.
- Touch: stick plus two buttons (jump, roll or duck) works on pad, keys and touch.
To lift theme above 3, the cut must be the verb: for example, the player calls "cut" to freeze the set and reset a beat mid take. Without that, it is a stunt runner with a film frame.
Rule 7h
Reusing the idea is fine. Rule 7h limits pre jam content (gameplay, levels, art); a concept is not content, and we may pitch any idea after the reveal. Conditions: nothing from lab/backlot is opened or copied during the build (no code, models, motion, audio, names of levels, UI); the character is rebuilt fresh in UE 5.9; and the dev log declares plainly that the idea comes from an in development studio game in three.js, with no assets carried over. One honesty note for the theme pitch: Backlot is in development, not shelved, so the dev log should not call it "our cut project".
scores-feasibility.md
Source theme-day/scores-feasibility.md. Last git commit 2026-11-11. About 833 words.
Feasibility scores (pipeline agent, Unreal and assets in one)
Feasibility only, 1 to 5, against the 12 hour greybox rule. Engine gate for UE 5.9 passed (MCP, Niagara, MetaSound, PCG, Geometry Script, packaging, OBS), so no take is penalised for engine risk alone. Hours are for the core verb greybox, not the finished game. Hard cuts and the 2 humanoid cap come from the PLAYBOOK gates.
| # | Take | Feas | Riskiest system | Greybox hours | Gate |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Projectionist | 4 | Creature that moves unseen in the dark plus the reel-splice mini interaction; the "unseen" test needs a clean line-of-sight and light check | 10 | Pass |
| 2 | Coverage | 5 | Fixed-camera cut logic that keeps player position consistent across shots; no locomotion animation at all | 8 | Pass |
| 3 | The Cutting Room Floor | 3 | A non-human player creature that must climb and move on the rig (we animate creatures ourselves in Unreal), plus projector-beam rooms | 14 | Pass (borderline on the 12 hour test) |
| 4 | Continuity | 4 | The "reference polaroid starts lying" state: per-prop target transforms and a capture-to-texture polaroid | 10 | Pass |
| 5 | Again, From the Top | 3 | Hunting crane AI plus Chaos set wrecking that must read as sabotage; fracture assets need prep and tuning | 14 | Pass |
| 6 | Theatrical vs Director's | 4 | Two full lighting and prop states per room flipped at runtime, with a hazard living only in one state | 10 | Pass |
| 7 | Rough Cut | 4 | Greybox pieces swapping to finished assets on KEEP (needs a bank of generated assets ready, though the stamp verb itself is trivial) | 9 | Pass |
| 8 | Dailies | 4 | Multi-camera render targets on screens and the footage timeline scrub; the thing's path must be consistent across feeds | 9 | Pass |
| 9 | Take Seventeen | 3 | Recording and replaying player runs as ghosts and assembling the best moments into a reel; a humanoid run/climb that looks right on Manny animations | 14 | Pass (near the cut line) |
| 10 | The Miniature | 3 | Hand-sized scale with reshapable terrain driving a path, plus an "empty costume" walker that needs a custom rig and walk | 14 | Pass |
Notes by take (what is strong, what is weak):
- Projectionist. A creature, lighting, haze, projector beam and sound are all on our strong list. The player is first person, so zero animated humanoids. Touch works as tap to move plus one splice button.
- Coverage. The easiest build: cameras, lights, a tap on a thumbnail and a hard cut with a MetaSound sting. It is the only take that is a clean 5, because it needs no walk cycle, no AI and no two-body contact.
- Cutting Room Floor. Core verb is a climb and a beam step. The creature is non-human (strength), but a platforming feel on pad and touch costs tuning time, and each projected scene is its own set to light.
- Continuity. First person, props and a lamp. The polaroid needs a render target or a baked image per prop state; doable, but the lying photo is where the hours go.
- Again, From the Top. Mechanical crane, no humanoid. Risk is the chase AI and Chaos breakage that stays teen-safe and reads in video.
- Theatrical vs Director's. Our proven Room That Changes work. Two light states per room is known; keep it to three rooms to stay inside the budget.
- Rough Cut. The verb is a stamp. The risk is the payoff: the world "finishing itself" needs generated and imported assets to be waiting, and a consistent look from TRELLIS props.
- Dailies. Cutting between cameras is close to Coverage. The thing's route across rooms must stay in sync, so give it a single spline and sample it per camera.
- Take Seventeen. A stunt run needs a running humanoid with real motion; we keep to Manny animation sets and one player body. Ghost replay is simple data capture, but the reel assembly step is extra.
- The Miniature. A scale trick through a camera and physics settings, but the empty costume walker is a custom rig and the path reshaping needs a nav or spline check that follows edited geometry.
Ranking by feasibility: Coverage (5), then Projectionist, Continuity, Theatrical vs Director's, Rough Cut, Dailies (all 4), then Cutting Room Floor, Again From the Top, Take Seventeen, The Miniature (all 3).
No take was cut by a gate. None needs multiplayer, a second level, more than 2 animated humanoids, or a non-teen-safe element. The four 3s sit one weak spot away from the under-3 cut line, so if the panel favours one, plan a fallback verb at hour 6.
scores-judge1.md
Source theme-day/scores-judge1.md. Last git commit 2026-11-11. About 691 words.
Scores, judge 1 (fresh panel)
Scored as an Epic MegaJam judge would, against PLAYBOOK "How to score". No feasibility; pipeline agents score that. Max 35.
| # | Take | Ambition | Theme | Fun | Gameplay | Visuals | Level design | Audio | Total |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Projectionist | 4 | 5 | 4 | 4 | 5 | 4 | 5 | 31 |
| 2 | Coverage | 5 | 5 | 4 | 4 | 4 | 4 | 4 | 30 |
| 3 | The Cutting Room Floor | 4 | 4 | 3 | 3 | 5 | 4 | 3 | 26 |
| 4 | Continuity | 3 | 4 | 4 | 4 | 4 | 4 | 3 | 26 |
| 5 | Again, From the Top | 4 | 3 | 5 | 4 | 5 | 4 | 4 | 29 |
| 6 | Theatrical vs Director's | 3 | 4 | 3 | 3 | 4 | 4 | 4 | 25 |
| 7 | Rough Cut | 4 | 4 | 3 | 2 | 4 | 3 | 3 | 23 |
| 8 | Dailies | 3 | 5 | 3 | 3 | 3 | 3 | 3 | 23 |
| 9 | Take Seventeen | 3 | 4 | 4 | 4 | 4 | 3 | 4 | 26 |
| 10 | The Miniature | 4 | 3 | 3 | 3 | 5 | 4 | 3 | 25 |
One line each
- Projectionist: the cut is literally the danger, the beam through haze sells Lumen, and the projector rattle plus changeover cue makes sound the mechanic; the booth seen from the auditorium is a moment judges remember.
- Coverage: the most original verb on the list (you move by cutting, a reverse shot opens a locked door); risk is that tapping cameras feels like a menu unless each cut lands hard.
- The Cutting Room Floor: the closest match to the host's pitch and a gorgeous tiny scale bay, but at heart it is a platformer, and the splice verb is thin.
- Continuity: clean, readable, cheap to polish; the lying polaroid is a good twist, but it sits in the spot the difference crowd.
- Again, From the Top: the most fun on a pad (wrecking a set with Chaos), but the theme reads as "retake loop", which judges saw all through "Here We Go Again" last year.
- Theatrical vs Director's: solid two state rooms with a voiced commentary payoff, but the flip mechanic is familiar and the theme is a label on it.
- Rough Cut: a clever meta joke and a great final Lumen sweep, but stamping KEEP or CUT is not much of a game, and greybox on screen risks a low visuals read.
- Dailies: the theme could not be clearer, but scrubbing monitors is a menu; low feel on a pad and little to show in the first 5 seconds of video.
- Take Seventeen: the end montage of your failures is a lovely payoff, but the run itself is a standard obstacle course.
- The Miniature: the pull back reveal is the best single shot on the list, but the theme is filmmaking in general, not a director's cut.
My bet for Best Overall: Projectionist
It scores high on every criterion with no weak spot, and that is what wins a seven criterion rubric judged by tired people. The theme lands in the first ten seconds (a reel in your hands, the screen goes black, the thing moves). The signature moment, finding yourself on the screen, is unique and makes a perfect video hook. Audio carries the play, which RESEARCH.md shows wins rankings (These Four Walls, 2025). One room means all the polish goes into one space. Coverage is the higher ceiling on ambition, and I would fold its best idea in if it fits: let a cut to black also move the player's view, not only the creature.
scores-judge2.md
Source theme-day/scores-judge2.md. Last git commit 2026-11-11. About 676 words.
Judge 2 scores (fresh panel, player and streamer view)
Scale 1 to 5. No feasibility score. "A stranger smiles in the first minute" weighed heavily under Fun.
| # | Take | Ambition | Theme | Fun | Gameplay | Visuals | Level | Audio | Total /35 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Projectionist | 4 | 4 | 4 | 4 | 5 | 4 | 5 | 30 |
| 2 | Coverage | 5 | 5 | 4 | 4 | 4 | 4 | 4 | 30 |
| 3 | The Cutting Room Floor | 4 | 5 | 3 | 3 | 5 | 4 | 3 | 27 |
| 4 | Continuity | 3 | 4 | 3 | 3 | 3 | 4 | 3 | 23 |
| 5 | Again, From the Top | 4 | 4 | 5 | 4 | 5 | 4 | 4 | 30 |
| 6 | Theatrical vs Director's | 3 | 4 | 3 | 3 | 4 | 3 | 4 | 24 |
| 7 | Rough Cut | 4 | 5 | 3 | 2 | 4 | 3 | 3 | 24 |
| 8 | Dailies | 3 | 5 | 2 | 3 | 3 | 3 | 3 | 22 |
| 9 | Take Seventeen | 3 | 4 | 4 | 3 | 4 | 3 | 4 | 25 |
| 10 | The Miniature | 4 | 3 | 3 | 3 | 4 | 4 | 2 | 23 |
One line each
- Projectionist: the creature three rows closer in the white flash is a real chat moment, but the first minute is threading reels, which reads as chores before it reads as scary.
- Coverage: the reverse-shot-through-a-locked-door gets a grin the first time, and I have never played it; the risk is that after five cuts it feels like a slideshow.
- The Cutting Room Floor: gorgeous premise and the host's own pitch, but the minute-one verb is platforming on film strips, which players have done many times.
- Continuity: a smart idea that plays like a tidying job until take 5; a stranger shrugs before the lying polaroid ever shows up.
- Again, From the Top: breaking a film set while a megaphone crane shouts "Again. From the top." makes people laugh inside 30 seconds, and smashing things on a pad feels good with no tutorial.
- Theatrical vs Director's: the flip is neat, but two-world switching is a jam staple, so the theme dresses an old mechanic.
- Rough Cut: the KEEP and CUT stamp is the most on-theme verb here, but stamping is a judgement, not play, and minute one looks like an unfinished game to a stranger.
- Dailies: the clearest editing fantasy, but scrubbing footage is slow and quiet, and streamers lose viewers on menus.
- Take Seventeen: your failures cut into a trailer at the end is a lovely payoff, but the first minute is a generic obstacle run.
- The Miniature: the pull-back reveal is great, but it comes at the end; up front it is a hard-to-read puzzle, and the film link is thin.
Top pick: Again, From the Top
Three takes tie on 30, so Fun breaks the tie, and this one has the highest Fun. It is the only take where the first minute is plainly fun to a stranger: a huge camera crane hunting you, a director's voice calling for another take, and you answering by wrecking the set. The theme flips nicely (you are the one ruining the director's cut), the reset line becomes a running gag streamers will repeat, and the final "Cut." is the payoff clip for the video. Coverage is the more original idea and my second choice. If the team wants innovation over instant fun, take Coverage, but make sure the hunter cutting into your shots shows up in minute two, not minute eight.
scores-judge3.md
Source theme-day/scores-judge3.md. Last git commit 2026-11-11. About 694 words.
Scores, judge 3 (UE tech art and level design lens)
Scale 1 to 5 per criterion, per PLAYBOOK "How to score". Feasibility not scored here. Weighted toward how each take shows off Lumen, Niagara and MetaSounds, and whether its one level teaches, builds and pays off.
| # | Take | Ambition | Theme | Fun | Gameplay | Visuals | Level | Audio | Total /35 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Projectionist | 4 | 5 | 4 | 4 | 5 | 5 | 5 | 32 |
| 2 | Coverage | 5 | 5 | 4 | 4 | 4 | 4 | 4 | 30 |
| 3 | The Cutting Room Floor | 4 | 5 | 3 | 3 | 5 | 4 | 3 | 27 |
| 4 | Continuity | 3 | 4 | 3 | 3 | 3 | 4 | 3 | 23 |
| 5 | Again, From the Top | 4 | 4 | 5 | 4 | 5 | 4 | 4 | 30 |
| 6 | Theatrical vs Director's | 3 | 4 | 4 | 4 | 5 | 4 | 4 | 28 |
| 7 | Rough Cut | 4 | 4 | 3 | 2 | 4 | 3 | 3 | 23 |
| 8 | Dailies | 3 | 5 | 3 | 3 | 3 | 3 | 3 | 23 |
| 9 | Take Seventeen | 3 | 4 | 4 | 3 | 4 | 3 | 4 | 25 |
| 10 | The Miniature | 4 | 3 | 3 | 3 | 4 | 4 | 2 | 23 |
One line each
- Projectionist: the beam through haze is a Lumen volumetric showpiece, Niagara dust and burning film come free, and the changeover cue makes MetaSounds the mechanic; one booth teaches threading, builds the creature's approach, and pays off when the screen shows the booth.
- Coverage: the most original verb on the list and every cut is a lit composition, but fixed angles mean we light shots rather than a space, and the hunter learning to cut is the only escalation.
- The Cutting Room Floor: projector beams over giant reels at tiny scale is a gorgeous Lumen and Niagara stage, but climbing film strips is a generic platformer verb and audio stays mostly ambient.
- Continuity: the polaroid lie is a good twist, yet one static room gives Lumen and Niagara little to do and the moving-prop loop is chores until take 5.
- Again, From the Top: Chaos wreckage, sparking rigs and a megaphone voice on a reset loop is the most fun read on a pad; the stage teaches by the first reset and pays off with the rig drop, though the reset can feel like the retake loop judges have seen.
- Theatrical vs Director's: two lighting states per room is the cleanest Lumen demo here and a MetaSounds crossfade on flip sells it, but the flip-world idea is familiar.
- Rough Cut: the one-sweep Lumen reveal is a killer trailer beat, but KEEP or CUT stamping is a menu verb and the greybox stretch fights our no-placeholder rule.
- Dailies: the clearest editing fantasy, but footage on monitors hides our lighting behind screens and scrubbing has thin pad feel.
- Take Seventeen: the montage ending is a great payoff and Chaos set pieces look good, but the run itself is a standard obstacle course with weak teaching of why takes matter until the end.
- The Miniature: the tabletop pull-back is a lovely reveal and miniature lighting suits Lumen, but the theme reads as filmmaking rather than director's cut, and sound has no job.
Top pick
Projectionist. It is the only take where all three showcase systems carry the mechanic (light is the screen, Niagara is the dying film, sound is the cue and the threat), and its single booth teaches, escalates and pays off on its own reflection. Coverage and Again, From the Top tie for second: Coverage for innovation, Again for fun.
scoresR2-feasibility.md
Source theme-day/scoresR2-feasibility.md. Last git commit 2026-11-11. About 1,047 words.
Round 2 feasibility scores (pipeline agent, Unreal and assets in one)
Feasibility only, 1 to 5, same method as scores-feasibility.md: core verb greybox against the 12 hour rule, no engine-risk penalty (UE 5.9 gate passed 2026-11-11 in prep/MCP-RUNBOOK.md: MCP drive, Niagara, MetaSound, PCG, Geometry Script, packaging, OBS). Hours are for the core verb greybox, not the finished game. Gates from the PLAYBOOK: feasibility under 3 cuts; more than 2 animated humanoids cuts; the feasibility row also says one level, no multiplayer, no PCG dependence, works on pad, touch and keys.
Weak spots applied: humanoid bodies, hands and fighting animation; two-body contact; multi-agent pathing (untested, so any take that needs it is scored as untested work, not as a known quantity).
| # | Take | Feas | Riskiest system | Greybox hours | Gate |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | The Shelf | 3 | Seven toys that each need their own flaw behaviour (walks backwards, bites, too loud) animated without a skeletal pipeline; the final rebuild from parts is a second system | 13 | Pass (borderline on the 12 hour test) |
| 2 | Ballast | 5 | Drag to rail on touch with a live weight gauge; the wind and rope repair loop is extra but cuttable | 7 | Pass |
| 3 | Prune | 3 | Grow-on-cut: PCG regenerating at runtime after a swipe, with light flowing along the surviving branches; the playbook row says no PCG dependence | 13 | Pass (borderline; becomes a 4 at 9 hours if built from pre-authored branch pieces that hide on cut) |
| 4 | Hive Mind | 3 | Moths as individual agents (one can refuse and reroute, losing one dims the room) on untested multi-agent pathing; a pure Niagara swarm cannot carry that gameplay | 14 | Pass (near the cut line) |
| 5 | Foreman of the Deep | 2 | Three robots with an order queue and personality-driven disobedience on untested multi-agent pathing, plus the cautious robot dragging the reckless one (two-body contact) | 18 | CUT (feasibility under 3) |
| 6 | The Unabridged | 4 | Scrape, wash or chip reveal on three surfaces: paint mask in a render target driven by touch swipe, with a layer state per surface that triggers a voiced line | 10 | Pass |
| 7 | Power Cut | 4 | A readable city of districts that go dark on tap with a demand and siren sim tuned to feel tense, plus the final lantern-lit control room as a second lighting state | 10 | Pass |
| 8 | Cut Stone | 3 | Faking a gem: authored light rigs and light functions that must read as refraction and reveal a hidden room per cut, across a combinatorial set of cuts; live slicing via Geometry Script is possible but should stay on preset planes | 13 | Pass (borderline on the 12 hour test) |
Notes by take:
- The Shelf. Props from TRELLIS and one room with state are strengths. The risk is the toy behaviours. Keep every toy a rigid prop with a driven motion (wind-up hop, roll, snap, hum) and no skeleton, and keep toys non-humanoid (animals, vehicles, spinning tops), and it holds at 3. Any doll with arms and legs breaks the weak spot rule.
- Ballast. The cleanest build of the round: physics objects, a gauge, a rail, dynamic sky and weather, local voices on a falling-item trigger. No humanoid, no AI, no contact. The only real hours are tuning the descent so the last minute lands on two items.
- Prune. PCG passed the engine gate as an editor-time graph. Regenerating a tree at runtime after each cut was not tested and the playbook row bars PCG dependence. If the fallback is taken (a pre-authored tree of spline-mesh branches, hide on cut, light travels by a material parameter), the build is easy and this is a 4. Decide at hour 6.
- Hive Mind. Niagara swarms are a strength. Individual moth decisions that change the game state are not particles and need real actors with pathing, which has never been tested. Plan the fallback now: a spline-following Niagara swarm plus about 8 actor moths as light sources, with the "refusal" moment authored as a scripted detour.
- Foreman of the Deep. Three agents with queued orders is the exact untested multi-agent pathing weak spot, and the rescue moment is two bodies in contact. Robots are non-human (a strength) and the lamp-only view is lighting we do well, so this is close to a 3 at best if cut to two robots on fixed spline routes with the rescue as an authored cutscene beat, which would drop the take's core idea. As pitched, it fails the gate.
- The Unabridged. Scrape-to-reveal is a render target paint mask, a known technique, and the statue is a static mesh (not an animated humanoid). Dawn and night are two lighting states of one village, which is the Room That Changes work we have done. The writing carries the take but that is not a build risk.
- Power Cut. The verb is a tap and the city is a diorama of instanced emissive blocks, so no humanoids. The hours go to the demand loop and to making the voiced hospital and kid calls land on the right beat. Keep to 6 to 8 districts.
- Cut Stone. Geometry Script passed the gate (plane cut, saved mesh read back), so a runtime cut is plausible, but the look is the work: Lumen does not refract, so the glow, caustics and hidden-room reveal are authored light functions. Use preset cut planes and swap pre-cut meshes, as the take itself suggests.
Ranking by feasibility: Ballast (5), then The Unabridged and Power Cut (4), then The Shelf, Prune, Hive Mind and Cut Stone (3), then Foreman of the Deep (2, cut).
Gate summary: one take cut (Foreman of the Deep, feasibility 2). None needs multiplayer, a second level, more than 2 animated humanoids or anything not teen safe. Four 3s sit one weak spot from the cut line; for Prune, Hive Mind and Cut Stone, name the fallback verb before the build starts and decide at hour 6.
scoresR2-judge1.md
Source theme-day/scoresR2-judge1.md. Last git commit 2026-11-11. About 569 words.
Round 2 scores, judge 1 (fresh panel)
Lens: an Epic MegaJam judge on entry 51 of the day, after a wall of film sets, cameras and "Cut!" gags. Literal film imagery now costs on Theme and Ambition; the theme has to live in the verb. No feasibility score.
| Take | Amb | Theme | Fun | Game | Vis | Level | Audio | Total | One line |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| The Shelf | 5 | 5 | 4 | 4 | 4 | 5 | 3 | 30 | The host's own "feature that didn't make it" pitch as a puzzle verb; CUT tags read instantly and nobody else will have it. |
| Ballast | 4 | 5 | 3 | 2 | 5 | 3 | 5 | 27 | Most moving read of "what goes in", but between drops my hands are idle; a judge will cry once and not replay. |
| Prune | 4 | 4 | 3 | 3 | 5 | 3 | 3 | 25 | Gorgeous and calm, yet "cut a branch" reads as gardening before it reads as Director's Cut. |
| Hive Mind | 4 | 4 | 3 | 3 | 5 | 4 | 3 | 26 | Directing a crew without a film set is fresh, but swarm control in a jam usually feels mushy. |
| Foreman of the Deep | 4 | 5 | 4 | 4 | 4 | 4 | 4 | 29 | Direction is the only power and the crew visibly has its own will; strong, though "command the bots" is a known genre. |
| The Unabridged | 4 | 4 | 3 | 3 | 4 | 4 | 4 | 26 | Scraping the sanitized legend to the uncut one is a clever read; lives or dies on the writing. |
| Power Cut | 3 | 3 | 3 | 3 | 4 | 3 | 4 | 23 | "Cut" as a pun and "director" as a job title; the weakest theme link and a management sim at heart. |
| Cut Stone | 4 | 3 | 3 | 3 | 5 | 3 | 2 | 23 | Beautiful light toy, but a gem's facets are a stretch from Director's Cut and audio has no role. |
| Projectionist | 3 | 3 | 4 | 3 | 5 | 4 | 5 | 27 | Best atmosphere on the board, but the 40th projection booth I saw today; theme feels like set dressing. |
| Coverage | 4 | 3 | 3 | 3 | 4 | 4 | 4 | 25 | A smart verb, still wrapped in film grammar every other entry also used; I stop reading it as fresh. |
| Again, From the Top | 2 | 2 | 4 | 3 | 4 | 3 | 4 | 22 | Soundstage, megaphone, "Cut." It is exactly the entry I already scored ten times today. |
Best Overall bet
The Shelf. It is the only take that answers the host's exact pitch (shelved features come back) without a single film prop, and its tagged-toy verb gives real puzzle depth. Foreman of the Deep is the close second and the safer gameplay bet. Round 1's finalists fall behind once the film-set fatigue is counted.
scoresR2-judge2.md
Source theme-day/scoresR2-judge2.md. Last git commit 2026-11-11. About 616 words.
Round 2 scores, judge 2 (player and streamer lens)
Criteria: Ambition, Theme, Fun, Gameplay, Visuals, Level, Audio (1 to 5 each, max 35). Heavy weight on whether a stranger smiles in the first minute.
| # | Take | Amb | Theme | Fun | Game | Vis | Level | Audio | Total | One line |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | The Shelf | 4 | 5 | 5 | 4 | 4 | 4 | 3 | 29 | Reading a "bites" tag and then using the biting toy gets a laugh in minute one, and it's still the host's own pitch. |
| 2 | Ballast | 4 | 5 | 3 | 2 | 4 | 3 | 5 | 26 | The ending will make chat go quiet, but the first minute is just dragging things to a rail, and strangers don't smile at that. |
| 3 | Prune | 3 | 4 | 3 | 3 | 4 | 3 | 3 | 23 | Lovely and calm, but swiping branches is a screensaver to most players, and PCG growth is a coin flip. |
| 4 | Hive Mind | 4 | 4 | 3 | 3 | 5 | 3 | 3 | 25 | Gorgeous swarm, but moths that do something dumb read as broken AI, not as a crew with opinions. |
| 5 | Foreman of the Deep | 4 | 5 | 5 | 4 | 4 | 4 | 4 | 30 | Yelling at a robot that ignores you is instant streamer gold, and the theme is the verb. |
| 6 | The Unabridged | 4 | 4 | 3 | 3 | 4 | 4 | 4 | 26 | Scraping is satisfying and the reveal is a good idea, but it all depends on writing nobody can judge until it exists. |
| 7 | Power Cut | 3 | 4 | 3 | 3 | 4 | 3 | 4 | 24 | A tense idea, but tapping districts plays like a menu, and the hospital call feels like a guilt trip. |
| 8 | Cut Stone | 4 | 3 | 3 | 3 | 5 | 3 | 2 | 23 | Best screenshot of the round, but preset slices make for thin play and "cut" is a pun more than the theme. |
| R1 | Coverage | 4 | 4 | 3 | 3 | 4 | 4 | 4 | 26 | Clever verb, but it's still a film set, and choosing shots feels like a menu until the hunter shows up. |
| R1 | Projectionist | 4 | 3 | 3 | 3 | 5 | 4 | 5 | 27 | Great mood and the best audio idea, but threading reels is a chore for strangers, and it's the literal read Don pushed back on. |
| R1 | Again, From the Top | 3 | 3 | 4 | 3 | 4 | 3 | 4 | 24 | Most laughs of round 1, but it's a retake loop on a soundstage, which is exactly what Don called too literal. |
Top pick: Foreman of the Deep
It's the only take where the theme is the whole verb (you direct, you never touch) and the first minute is funny. A robot misreads your order, you groan, and you want one more try. It also tells our Glass Box story without saying so. The Shelf is a close second and the better puzzle game. If Foreman's three-robot pathing scares the pipeline, The Shelf is my pick.
scoresR2-judge3.md
Source theme-day/scoresR2-judge3.md. Last git commit 2026-11-11. About 607 words.
Round 2 scores, judge 3 (UE technical artist and level designer)
Lens: does Lumen, Niagara or MetaSounds carry the mechanic, and does the one level teach, build and pay off. Round 1 takes judged against Don's "too literal" note, so their Theme scores sit lower.
| Take | Amb | Theme | Fun | Game | Vis | Level | Audio | Total | One line |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Prune | 5 | 4 | 4 | 3 | 5 | 4 | 4 | 29 | Light moving through the branches you keep is Lumen as the verb, and the roof cut is a real payoff; PCG breaks the playbook rule, so fake regrowth with authored branch sets swapped per cut. |
| Projectionist (R1) | 4 | 3 | 4 | 3 | 5 | 4 | 5 | 28 | Best light and sound as mechanic on the board, but it is the film set Don called too literal. |
| The Shelf | 4 | 4 | 4 | 4 | 3 | 5 | 3 | 27 | Best level design here: each tag teaches a rule, rooms stack them, the rebuild pays it all off; Lumen and Niagara are decoration. |
| Hive Mind | 4 | 4 | 4 | 4 | 5 | 3 | 3 | 27 | Niagara swarm as the agent and its light as health is gorgeous systemic tech; swarm readability will fight the level for clarity. |
| Foreman of the Deep | 4 | 4 | 4 | 4 | 4 | 4 | 3 | 27 | Lamps as your only vision makes Lumen the fog of war; solid, but three AI pawns is the heaviest build here. |
| The Unabridged | 4 | 4 | 3 | 3 | 4 | 4 | 4 | 26 | Layered material scrape via render target is proven tech and the door payoff lands; the whole thing rests on the writing. |
| Cut Stone | 5 | 4 | 3 | 3 | 5 | 3 | 3 | 26 | Caustics revealing a hidden room is a showpiece, but true refraction is the weak spot of Lumen and the room is small. |
| Coverage (R1) | 4 | 4 | 3 | 3 | 4 | 4 | 4 | 26 | Most original verb of round 1 and safest build; still cameras. |
| Ballast | 3 | 5 | 3 | 2 | 4 | 3 | 5 | 25 | Cleanest theme read and voiced drops make audio the payoff, but the basket is one static spot with little to do. |
| Power Cut | 3 | 3 | 3 | 3 | 4 | 3 | 4 | 23 | Districts going dark is a nice Lumen beat; plays as a menu over a diorama. |
| Again, From the Top (R1) | 3 | 3 | 4 | 3 | 4 | 3 | 3 | 23 | Fun Chaos toy, literal set, retake loop judges have seen. |
Top pick: Prune
The only take where cutting, light and the final shape are the same act, and it reads in one swipe on touch. The greenhouse is one space that grows with the player: teach on low branches, build to the canopy, pay off at the glass roof. Condition: no runtime PCG. Author 3 to 4 growth states per limb, blend with material masks and Niagara light flow, and add a MetaSound tone per branch so the tree is also an instrument.
takes-A.md
Source theme-day/takes-A.md. Last git commit 2026-11-11. About 1,059 words.
Takes from Agent A: the literal and its flip
Theme: "Director's Cut". Engine: UE 5.9. Lenses: plain meaning, the opposite, the theme as the rule of the world, the theme as the enemy.
The first idea a thousand entrants will have: you drag clips on an editing timeline, or you sit in a director's chair and tell actors where to stand. Both are menus, not play, and the second needs many animated humanoids. None of the takes below uses a timeline UI, and none needs more than one humanoid.
1. Night Shoot (plain meaning)
- Pitch: You direct one take of a 1950s creature feature on a soundstage at night, calling fog, lights and the rubber suit monster on cue, until the monster stops waiting for its cue.
- Core verb: call the cue: aim and fire light, fog and sound at the right beat as the camera dolly rolls.
- Signature moment: On the last take you shout "Cut!" and the creature keeps walking toward the camera. The set lights you placed are now the only thing between you and it.
- Shape: 1, Lightkeeper (with a rhythm layer).
- Why it reads in 60 s: clapperboard, "Action!", a red tally light and a slate that counts takes. The player is literally directing within ten seconds.
- Strengths: creature, fog, Lumen and voice all play to the pipeline. Zero animated humanoids (the director is you, unseen).
2. The Cut Scene (the opposite: what was cut)
- Pitch: You are the monster cut from the final film, wandering a film vault of discarded reels, and you climb back into the movie one projected scene at a time.
- Core verb: step into a projector beam to enter that scene, then reach its exit before the reel runs out.
- Signature moment: The last beam is the premiere. You crawl out of the screen into a theater of empty seats while the credits roll over you, restoring the director's cut by force.
- Shape: 13, Last Exit (rooms reached through light, nods to 1).
- Why it reads in 60 s: a reel labeled "DELETED SCENE 4", a film strip with your silhouette scratched out, the projector hum. The host's own pitch ("the feature that didn't make it") is the story.
- Strengths: the player is a non humanoid creature; projected scenes can be stylized black and white sets.
3. No Cuts (the opposite: the shot that never cuts)
- Pitch: You are the camera operator in a single unbroken horror take, and the rule of cinema holds: anything outside the frame can move, anything inside the frame cannot.
- Core verb: frame: keep the threat in shot while you back through the house to the exit.
- Signature moment: Two creatures, one lens. You must choose which one to keep in frame while the other closes in off screen, heard only on the boom mic.
- Shape: 8, Shadow Run (frame instead of shadow), close to 5.
- Why it reads in 60 s: the screen is a viewfinder with REC, a timecode and frame lines. Turn away and you hear it move.
- Strengths: camera work is our best area; creatures read well; sound is the mechanic. Risk: the "statue that moves when unseen" idea exists, so the twist is the viewfinder and the two creatures.
4. Coverage (the theme as the rule of the world)
- Pitch: A haunted house that obeys edit grammar: you do not walk, you cut, and whatever the next shot frames is where you are.
- Core verb: choose the next shot from fixed cameras (wide, close up, reverse, insert).
- Signature moment: A locked door. Cut to the reverse angle and you are on the other side. Later the thing hunting you learns to cut too, and appears in your insert shot.
- Shape: 2, The Room That Changes (one house, many angles).
- Why it reads in 60 s: shot names on screen ("WIDE", "REVERSE", "INSERT: KEY"), a hard cut sound, and the first puzzle is solved by a reverse shot.
- Strengths: touch is natural (tap a shot thumbnail); no locomotion animation needed; lighting each angle is our strength. Most original of the six.
5. Theatrical vs Director's (the theme as the rule of the world, two states)
- Pitch: Every room exists in two cuts: the safe theatrical version and the director's cut the studio deleted, and you flip between them to get through.
- Core verb: flip the cut: switch the room between versions to open paths, then flip back before what lives in the director's cut reaches you.
- Signature moment: The final room has no theatrical version. The director's commentary, voiced over the whole level, admits why the scene was cut, and you play it.
- Shape: 2, The Room That Changes, with 5 Spot the Change in the flip.
- Why it reads in 60 s: a menu card style toggle labeled THEATRICAL and DIRECTOR'S CUT, and the first flip changes the room in front of you.
- Strengths: a voiced commentary track plays to our local voices; two lighting states per room is proven work.
6. Again, From the Top (the theme as the enemy)
- Pitch: The Director is the monster: a camera crane with one great lens hunts you across the stage, reshooting your escape until it is perfect, and you win by ruining the film.
- Core verb: sabotage: break props, kill lights and wreck the set so no take can be used.
- Signature moment: Each failed take, the set resets and the voice says "Again. From the top." On the final take you drop the lighting rig on the crane, and the last word is yours: "Cut."
- Shape: 4, Break It Right (Chaos fracture on set pieces).
- Why it reads in 60 s: the crane looms, a red REC light finds you, a megaphone voice calls "Action."
- Strengths: a mechanical creature, not a humanoid; Chaos and Niagara set damage; one stage. Also echoes our own story: the agents' director made into a villain, a fine Glass Box dev log joke.
My ranking
4 (Coverage) for originality and touch fit, then 6 (Again, From the Top) for fun, then 1 (Night Shoot) for the clearest 60 second read.
takes-B.md
Source theme-day/takes-B.md. Last git commit 2026-11-11. About 1,095 words.
Theme day takes, Agent B (role and scale)
Theme: "Director's Cut". Lenses: the unexpected role, change size or shape, switch roles halfway, help or hinder someone who plays themselves.
The first idea a thousand entrants will have: you are the director, you yell "cut" and rearrange shots or actors. Every take below puts the player somewhere else on the set.
B1. The Projectionist
- Pitch: A lone projectionist in a dying 1950s movie palace keeps a horror film running while the thing on screen keeps getting out, and splicing the reel is how you put it back.
- Core verb: splice: cut a strip of film and tape a different frame in, and the creature in the auditorium jumps to wherever that frame puts it.
- Signature moment: the screen shows the booth window from the auditorium side, with you inside it. You have to cut that frame before the creature's frame reaches it.
- Shape: 1 Lightkeeper (the projector beam is the light tool), with a touch of 2.
- Theme in 60 s: you hold a reel and a splicer in the first ten seconds, and every cut visibly changes what happens. It is a director's cut done with your hands.
- Pipeline fit: one interior, volumetric beam through haze, Niagara dust, one non-human creature, zero humanoids. Touch: tap a frame, tap a slot.
B2. Continuity
- Pitch: You are the continuity clerk on a haunted night shoot. Between takes the set drifts, and you put every prop back before the cameras roll again, but some props won't stay put.
- Core verb: compare the polaroid of take 1 with the set and move each prop back to its mark.
- Signature moment: in take 5 the polaroid itself has changed. Now you have to decide which one is lying, the set or the photo, and the "wrong" choice films something that wasn't on the call sheet.
- Shape: 5 Spot the Change, with Exit 8's twist inverted: you don't walk past anomalies, you physically undo them against a clock.
- Theme in 60 s: slate clap, "reset for take 2", the polaroid pops up. Everyone knows what continuity is from blooper reels.
- Pipeline fit: one photoreal room, cheap reuse, no humanoids on set (the crew is voices on a walkie). Builds on our continuity ledger habit, which makes a fine dev log angle.
B3. Stand-In
- Pitch: You are the stunt double, a faceless wooden mannequin, run through the deadly set piece so the star doesn't have to, and the director's voice rewrites the stunt between takes.
- Core verb: run the gauntlet and hit the marks (taped Xs on the floor) as fire, collapse and swinging rigs go off on cue.
- Signature moment: the final take is "the director's cut" of the stunt: every set piece you survived fires at once, and you see your earlier takes replay as ghost mannequins running beside you.
- Shape: 13 Last Exit, with 4 Break It Right for the set pieces.
- Theme in 60 s: "Action!", a megaphone voice, chalk marks and a clapper. You are obviously the double.
- Pipeline fit: the mannequin dodges the humanoid problem (stylized, faceless, stiff on purpose). Chaos fracture, Niagara fire, a strong voice role. Risk: one character animation set still has to feel good.
B4. The Miniature
- Pitch: You are the model maker on an old effects film, hand-sized among your own miniature city, and the monster costume walking the set is no longer an actor.
- Core verb: reshape the miniature (tip buildings, lay a rail, pull a light) so the creature's path is the one the script needs, all while you're tiny inside it.
- Signature moment: a slow pull-back reveals the whole stage: your entire level was a tabletop, and the "monster" is an empty suit with the lights off, still walking.
- Shape: 7 The Diorama, with a scale shift.
- Theme in 60 s: you start on the shooting stage at full scale, shrink into the model, and the director's script page tells you the shot. It reads as filmmaking immediately.
- Pipeline fit: scale is a camera trick our agents are good at; Geometry Script and miniature lighting; one non-human creature. Touch: drag and tap.
B5. Final Girl, Final Cut
- Pitch: You play the creature in a slasher film for the first half and the screaming survivor in the second, and the second half uses your own first half as the monster.
- Core verb: first half, stalk and stage scares in the house; second half, survive what you staged.
- Signature moment: the role switch is the cut. The film stops, a splice rolls, and every trap and cue you laid comes back at you, with your own creature as the AI ghost replaying your path.
- Shape: 8 Shadow Run, with 3's replay.
- Theme in 60 s: "Scene 1: the creature" on a slate, then you sneak and frighten. The halfway cut makes the theme click.
- Pipeline fit: two characters, one stylized creature and one survivor seen in first person, so only one animated body. Teen safe: scares, no gore. Risk: two halves is double the design.
B6. The Extra
- Pitch: You are a background extra in a big period epic who keeps drifting into frame, and the director keeps recutting the scene around you until you take it over.
- Core verb: move through the crowd scene to hit or dodge the camera's frame, watched live in a monitor in the corner.
- Signature moment: the director gives up, and the final cut is your walk, played back on the premiere screen with music and credits rising, with the film's title replaced by your character's name.
- Shape: 8 Shadow Run inverted (the camera is the guard; sometimes you want to be seen).
- Theme in 60 s: the on-screen monitor and the director's "who is that?" over the speaker tell the joke right away.
- Pipeline fit: the weakest on our pipeline: crowds mean humanoids. Only works if the crowd is cardboard cutouts or silhouettes, which can be the joke. Lightest on horror. I would rank it last.
My ranking
- B1 The Projectionist: the most ours (horror, light, one room, no bodies), and splicing is the theme as a verb.
- B2 Continuity: cheapest build, strong horror twist, a dev log story.
- B4 The Miniature: best signature reveal; scale needs care.
- B5, then B3, then B6.
takes-C.md
Source theme-day/takes-C.md. Last git commit 2026-11-11. About 1,250 words.
Takes C: time, space and frame
Agent C, theme day, 2026-11-11. Theme: "Director's Cut".
The first idea everyone will have: you are a film director on a set, calling "action" and "cut" while actors perform, then you edit a movie together. It needs many acting humanoids (our weak spot) and it plays as a menu. A close second is the plain "retake loop", which also echoes last year's theme ("Here We Go Again"), so judges have seen a hundred of them. Every take below either avoids those or names the twist that makes it different.
1. The Cutting Room Floor
- Pitch: You are a deleted scene, alive in the dark of an editing bay, climbing the reels and the bins of discarded film to splice yourself back into the final cut before the projector starts.
- Core verb: climb and splice: walk across strips of lit film, and at each splice point drop a frame in to bridge a gap.
- Signature moment: you reach the projector gate and see your own scene play on the big screen for the audience, but the cut you made decides which version runs, and the frames you skipped flicker at the edges as ghosts.
- Shape: 7, The Diorama (a giant editing bay at tiny scale), with a touch of 1, Lightkeeper (the projector beam is the goal light).
- Why it reads in 60 seconds: the first shot is a film strip with a missing frame, the word CUT stamped in grease pencil, and a tiny figure standing on it. "I am the cut content" lands before the first jump. The host's own pitch was the feature that didn't make it; this makes that literal and playable.
2. Final Cut: The Hallway
- Pitch: One photoreal hotel corridor that the unseen director keeps recutting; each time you walk it, scenes are trimmed, reordered or inserted, and you must spot what the editor changed and walk out in the version the director wants.
- Core verb: look and decide (keep going, or turn back), the anomaly loop with film grammar: a jump cut, a missing door, a continuity error, a scene played twice.
- Signature moment: a timeline overlay appears on the wall like an editing program, and you watch your own last walk scrubbed backward; the creature that was "cut" in an earlier pass is still standing in the frames you didn't watch.
- Shape: 5, Spot the Change. Why it differs from the thousand anomaly games: the changes are edits (cuts, inserts, reversed clips, a dropped frame), so the anomaly rule is the theme, not wallpaper.
- Why it reads in 60 seconds: each loop opens on a slate ("Scene 3, Take 4") and a hard cut you can feel; by the second walk the player knows they are inside someone's edit.
3. Projectionist
- Pitch: Alone in an old cinema's booth at night, you keep the reels running while something in the dark auditorium moves only when the picture cuts to black.
- Core verb: keep it running: thread reels, swap at the changeover cue, trim burning film, and choose when to let the screen go dark.
- Signature moment: the cue marks flash in the corner of the screen; if you miss the changeover, the picture goes white and in that flash you see the thing is now three rows closer. In the final reel the film on screen is the booth itself, filmed from the auditorium, and you are in it.
- Shape: 6, Keep It Running, with a horror creature as the pressure (one non-human, mostly unseen).
- Why it reads in 60 seconds: reels, cue dots, a projector beam through smoke: every judge knows the image, and the danger is literally the cut. One booth, one distant creature, strong voice and sound work.
4. Rough Cut
- Pitch: The level arrives as a director's rough cut: greybox walls, temp lights, placeholder sound and director's notes pinned in the air, and as you play through it you approve or cut each piece and watch the world finish itself around you.
- Core verb: walk and judge: point at an element (a wall, a light, a sound, a monster) and stamp KEEP or CUT.
- Signature moment: the last room is the director's favourite, the scene everyone told them to cut. You can keep it, and the whole level swaps to its full photoreal final grade in one Lumen sweep, or cut it and walk out in silence.
- Shape: 2, The Room That Changes (state per decision), stretched to one short linear level.
- Why it reads in 60 seconds: the meta is visible at once: unfinished set pieces, notes that say "temp, replace", and the world snaps to finished art the moment you approve it. It also tells our real story (one person directing agents) without a word of AI talk. Risk: the greybox look must read as intentional, so it stays a short opening, not the whole game (Don sees no placeholder art outside the joke).
5. Dailies
- Pitch: A night watchman rewatches one night of security footage on an editing desk, cutting between cameras, and must assemble the version of events that shows where the thing in the building really went.
- Core verb: cut between angles and scrub time: pick a camera, scrub, mark an in and out point.
- Signature moment: in the assembled final cut, played back at the end, the creature turns to look straight down the lens of a camera you never had on your desk.
- Shape: 11, Six Choices (each cut is a timed choice), with the investigation feel of 3, The Ten Minute Loop, without real schedules: the footage is pre-made Sequencer shots.
- Why it reads in 60 seconds: a bank of monitors, a timeline, a razor tool: the player is literally editing. Built from what agents do best (cameras, light, Sequencer), and the one creature is seen only in footage, so no animated humanoid is close up.
6. Take Seventeen
- Pitch: A stunt sequence on a vast night backlot, filmed by a single moving camera crane; every failed attempt becomes a "take", and the director's cut is a montage of your best moments stitched from all of them.
- Core verb: run and time (a short escape run through set pieces that fall, burn and collapse on cue).
- Signature moment: at the end the game plays your director's cut: the best bits from every take, edited to the score with real cuts, so your failures become the trailer. Different from the plain retake loop: the takes are not a punishment to erase; they are footage you keep and edit.
- Shape: 13, Last Exit, with 4, Break It Right in the set pieces (Chaos facades on cue).
- Why it reads in 60 seconds: a clapperboard snaps "Take 1", the set fires up, you fall, "Cut! Take 2" in a director's voice. The player is a small, distant figure in a stylized stunt suit, filmed wide, which hides our body and hand weakness.
My pick to push
3, Projectionist for fit to our strengths (one set, horror creature, light through smoke, voice and sound as the mechanic) with 1, The Cutting Room Floor as the most original and the closest to the host's own framing. 2, Final Cut: The Hallway is the safest build but sits in a crowded genre.
takes-R2.md
Source theme-day/takes-R2.md. Last git commit 2026-11-11. About 1,393 words.
Round 2 takes (Wed Nov 11)
Don's note on round 1: too literal. Hard rule this round: no film sets, cameras, projectors, actors, editing bays, movie palaces, scripts or "take" imagery. The theme lives in the mechanic and the meaning.
Shape numbers refer to the bank in prep/PLAYBOOK.md.
1. The Shelf (reading 1)
- Pitch: A night janitor in a toy factory's sealed prototype vault wakes the toys that were cut from production, and each one only works the way its shelved design said it would.
- Core verb: Pick a cut prototype off the shelf, read its rejection tag ("too loud", "walks backwards", "bites"), and place it where its flaw solves a room.
- Signature moment: The final door needs the one toy the company destroyed. You rebuild it from parts of all the others, and it works exactly as first drawn.
- Why a judge gets it in 60 seconds: Every toy carries a stamped CUT tag with the reason it was shelved. Shelved features coming back to finish the job is the host's own pitch, told with toys.
- Shape: 2 (The Room That Changes), with 7 elements.
- Biggest risk: Toys can read as twee. They need the photoreal, slightly wrong look (dusty, half painted) to land the eerie tone.
2. Ballast (reading 2)
- Pitch: Your hot air balloon is sinking over a dark sea toward a lit island, and the only way to stay up is to throw your life's things overboard.
- Core verb: Drag an object to the rail and drop it; every item weighs in kilos and memory, and a short voiced line plays as it falls.
- Signature moment: In the last minute only two things are left, the wedding photo and the music box, and the balloon needs one more gone. What you kept is what the island shows you on landing.
- Why a judge gets it in 60 seconds: It is "decide what goes in and what doesn't" with a gauge, and the landing is literally your final cut of a life.
- Shape: 11 (Six Choices) over 12 (Weather Hand) for the storm and wind.
- Biggest risk: Thin on gameplay. Wind, rope repairs and storm gusts must give the hands work between drops.
3. Prune (reading 2)
- Pitch: You tend one ancient, glowing tree in a ruined greenhouse, and every branch you cut sends its light and life into the branches you keep.
- Core verb: Swipe to cut a branch; the PCG tree regrows through what remains and the cut light flows along it.
- Signature moment: The tree has grown into the greenhouse roof, and your last cut decides whether it breaks the glass to the night sky or bends back to light the room.
- Why a judge gets it in 60 seconds: Cutting is the only verb, and the shape of the finished tree is your final cut. No two players end with the same tree.
- Shape: 1 (Lightkeeper) with 7 (The Diorama) framing.
- Biggest risk: Procedural growth that looks good every time. PCG is proven, but grow-on-cut needs early test builds.
4. Hive Mind (reading 3)
- Pitch: You are the will of a colony of glowing moths in a flooded cathedral; you set where they go, they decide how, and each moth you lose takes its light with it.
- Core verb: Draw a path or tap a goal; the swarm (Niagara) carries it out, sometimes cleverly, sometimes badly.
- Signature moment: A moth refuses an order and finds a better route than yours, and the game lets you keep its version.
- Why a judge gets it in 60 seconds: Set the vision, delegate, accept or reject what the crew does. It is the host's AI agents line with moths, and it mirrors our Glass Box story.
- Shape: 8 (Shadow Run) with 1 (Lightkeeper).
- Biggest risk: Readable swarm AI in 92 hours. Keep the moths dumb and the rooms tuned so "clever" moments are authored.
5. Foreman of the Deep (reading 3)
- Pitch: From a diving bell on the sea floor you direct three salvage robots with odd personalities through a sunken liner, and you can only see what their lamps see.
- Core verb: Pick a robot, give one order (go, lift, cut, light, wait), switch to the next; their own habits change how they obey.
- Signature moment: The cautious robot finally disobeys and drags the reckless one out of a collapse while you scream orders it ignores.
- Why a judge gets it in 60 seconds: You never touch the world yourself. Your only power is direction, and the crew is visibly not you.
- Shape: 2 (The Room That Changes) with 8 (Shadow Run).
- Biggest risk: Three agents' pathing and order queue. Cap at three verbs per robot and short rooms.
6. The Unabridged (reading 4)
- Pitch: A village's cheerful saint statue tells a sweet legend in the square at dawn; at night you peel back the restorations, layer by layer, to find what the founders painted over.
- Core verb: Scrape, wash or chip a surface (statue, mural, gravestone) to reveal the older layer, and each layer changes the voiced legend.
- Signature moment: The final layer is not paint but a door, and the uncut myth plays in full as you walk into it.
- Why a judge gets it in 60 seconds: The sanitized version and the uncut version live on the same wall, and the player physically scrapes from one to the other.
- Shape: 5 (Spot the Change) with 2.
- Biggest risk: Writing has to carry it. The myth needs to be good, not just "dark secret", and pass the no AI tells bar.
7. Power Cut (reading 5)
- Pitch: The night supervisor of a city's grid has ten minutes of power left and the whole city in front of her as a glowing model; she chooses which districts go dark.
- Core verb: Tap a district to cut or restore it; demand rises, sirens answer, and lights die in what you could not save.
- Signature moment: The last cut is your own control room, and you finish the night by lantern while the city shows your choices.
- Why a judge gets it in 60 seconds: "Cut" as the verb and "director" as the job title, with the final city map as the cut.
- Shape: 6 (Keep It Running) with 7 (The Diorama).
- Biggest risk: Reads as a management sim. It needs a human stake (a voiced call from the hospital, a kid on the line) and must stay tense, not spreadsheet.
8. Cut Stone (reading 5)
- Pitch: A gem cutter's last commission is a huge raw stone that holds a trapped light, and each facet you cut decides how it shines and what it shows.
- Core verb: Rotate the stone and slice a plane; the light inside refracts into the dark workshop and reveals a hidden room in its shadows.
- Signature moment: One wrong cut cracks the stone, and the broken half shines a path you never meant to find.
- Why a judge gets it in 60 seconds: Cutting is the art, every cut is permanent, and the finished gem is uniquely yours.
- Shape: 1 (Lightkeeper) with 14 (Pieces on the Board).
- Biggest risk: Real-time mesh slicing and refraction. Fake it with preset cut planes and authored light rigs.
Reading 1, literal option (checked, not pitched)
Don's backlog (game-ideas-backlog.md) holds Booster Seat, the football exploitation satire, SBM and others. None fits one level, ten minutes, teen-safe and no-humanoids at once (SBM is 18+ fighting; the satires lean on human bodies and real-feeling leagues). "The Shelf" keeps the idea instead: the cut features ARE the game. The Glass Box dev log can still name our own shelved features.
Top 3
- Ballast: the clearest theme read, emotional, no humanoids on screen, and the dropped objects show off our props, voices and weather.
- The Shelf: the host's own framing made physical, strongest puzzle depth, and eerie without forcing horror.
- Foreman of the Deep: the directing reading with no humans, photoreal underwater, and our studio's own story for the dev log.